Gay Nineties Pizza Co

Located in the heart of Pleasanton, California, Gay Nineties Pizza Co serves up a delightful blend of classic Italian and European flavors, perfectly tailored for pizza lovers and pasta enthusiasts alike. This inviting pizza restaurant is a local gem, renowned for its thick, flavorful dough and carefully balanced blend of toppings that promise to satisfy both casual diners and connoisseurs of authentic Italian fare.

Step inside, and you’ll immediately sense the warm, friendly atmosphere where attentive service complements the delicious offerings. Diners consistently sing praises of the welcoming staff, with servers like Meghan, Garrett, and Conner going above and beyond to make each visit special. Friendly, genuine hospitality here doesn’t feel scripted—it’s the kind of care that leaves a lasting impression, making you feel right at home.

The menu at Gay Nineties Pizza Co is a comforting celebration of Italian classics. Popular choices include the iconic Frank’s Special Pizza Lunch, a hearty combination of meat and veggies that strikes a perfect balance of savory and fresh. For those who crave a spicy kick, the BBQ Chicken Pizza Lunch offers tender chicken glazed in smoky barbecue sauce atop a luscious cheese layer. Traditionalists will relish the generous slices of Pepperoni Pizza and the delightful roll of Pepperoni and Mushroom Large Pizza, where robust flavors meld beautifully with a crisp, golden crust.

The appetizers themselves are a tempting start to any meal. The Fried Zucchini and Mozzarella Sticks bring a perfect crunch, while the Antipasto Platter offers a variety of olives, mushrooms, and cured meats that tease the palate with authentic Mediterranean notes. Customers also rave about the Cheesy Garlic Bread—comforting and rich, though some visitors wish for a bit more garlic punch, the warm, melty cheese remains a definite crowd-pleaser.

Not to be overlooked are the pasta dishes, which truly speak to the heart of classic Italian dining. Whether you choose the delicate Prawns Provencal with Angel Hair Pasta, the rich, saucy Lasagna, or the creamy indulgence of Fettuccini with Alfredo or Pesto Cream Sauce, each plate bursts with fresh, vibrant flavors that transport you straight to Italy’s coastlines and rustic kitchens.

For a lighter touch, the Caesar Salad and Cobb Salad are crisp and refreshing, pairing beautifully with the richness of the main courses. The house even includes a side of Meatballs or Homemade Bread Pudding for those with a sweet tooth or desire for a traditional finish to the meal.

Patrons consistently marvel at the generous portions and reasonable prices—two qualities that make Gay Nineties Pizza Co a wonderful choice whether you're stopping in for a quick lunch or enjoying a leisurely dinner with friends. Many have mentioned that just two slices of their pizza can satisfy the heartiest appetite, thanks to the perfectly thick dough and abundant cheese that never skimp on authenticity.

In all, Gay Nineties Pizza Co feels like a neighborhood treasure where every bite tells a story of love, tradition, and culinary passion. If you find yourself in Pleasanton craving a genuine slice of Italy with a side of exceptional service, this is the place to savor every moment and every mouthwatering morsel.